Advertising Information

What Is Most Important - Copy Or Pic?


When, some little time ago now, I first descended upon the advertising scene, we were a good deal more concerned than most people seem to be today about the nature of the business we found ourselves in. We were always holding debates - in the saloon bar of the Coach & Horses in New Bond Street, to be tiresomely precise - about the meaning of advertising, the significance of advertising, and the past, present and future of advertising. And an unconscionably serious lot we no doubt were. Not to mention drunk.

Among the hardy perennials of our debates was the relevance of sex in advertising, and also the question of whether the copy element in ads was more important than the visual or vice versa.

Of course, these were the days when it was possible for agency personnel to slope off round the pub during working hours and nobody on the management side of things turned so much as a hair at our absence. Just so long as the work got done on time, nobody gave so much as a tinker's cuss whether you were doing it in the office or down at the dog track. These days, agencies are a little more sanguine in their approach to creative people; and I recently heard of a designer being sacked on the spot for turning up at a client meeting wearing jeans - and I kid you not.

But back to our hardy perennials. The 'sex in advertising' question was a hotly debated topic, mainly because the copywriters and designers in my milieu were always anxious to attend the relevant photo-shoots, and not because sex was liable to help sell anything. Thus, we were constantly coming up with speculative ad campaigns that featured semi-clad females so that we might catch a glimpse of a naked thigh or better. Few of these concepts saw the light of day, but it was always worth a try.

As to the copy versus pic argument, this has still not been resolved to this day. Then, as now, I was on the side of the angels, holding that around 80 per cent of ads could, at a pinch, do without illustrations, whereas only about 2 per cent could do without words. (In regard to the other 18 per cent, you can make your own arrangements.)

Such an argument, as you'd expect, was met with widespread alarm by the designers, who saw that I was presaging their redundancy. Then as now, they would do everything they could to give their illustrations the prominence they thought they deserved. This usually resulted in a design in which the pic took up four-fifths of the ad, while the copy was relegated to eight-point solid and rendered practically illegible.

My attitude, obviously, was simply a debating stance - true though it undoubtedly is. I am not suggesting for a moment that 8 out of 10 ads should be wholly typographical. But if you take a dispassionate look around you, you might agree with me that a whole lot of ads (and brochures and websites, too, come to that) carry pictures for pictures' sake; and that in quite a few cases the pictures, far from helping the transmission of a message, actually hinder it.

The biggest offenders in this respect are what might be describes as semi-industrial ads. Just leaf through a trade mag (or brochure or website) and you'll see irrelevance in illustration well carried out. You'll see, for instance, pictures of the factory or, as they call it these days, the production operation. You'll see pics of two obvious male models in white coats staring idiotically at a computer screen or a blueprint. And you'll see pics of two obvious male models, plus a female model, in white coats staring idiotically at a computer screen. The female is included in the latter pic because the designer had originally planned for her to be shot with her clothes off.

Here's what I think. With today's wonderful digital photography opportunities, with an instant replay of whatever has been shot, one might hope that illustrations in ads, brochures and websites might be made more relevant. They might actually show the product in action - demonstration is, after all, the soul of advertising. But, no, we still get pics which have nothing whatsoever to do with the product or its benefits.

I don't mind admitting that there can be few people in the whole wide world who know less about photography than I do. What I do know, however, is that promotional material is far better off without an illustration if that illustration does not augment the sales message. So, in this respect, copy is more important than illustration.

Mind you, there is a lot of copy around that doesn't augment the sales message either. But that's another story.

About The Author

Patrick Quinn is an award winning copywriter with 40 years' experience of the advertising business in London, Miami, Dublin and Edinburgh.

He publishes a FREE online monthly newsletter, AdBriefing, designed for those who have a very real interest in producing good advertising. Subscriptions are available at: http://www.adbriefing.com

j.p@markethillpublishing.co.uk


MORE RESOURCES:

Los Angeles Times

Private Matters: Senate Hearing To Debate Web-Based Targeted Ads
CRN, NY - 9 hours ago
At the heart of the hearing of the Senate Commerce Committee titled Privacy Implications of Online Advertising are proposed tools used by ISPs to track ...
Broadband Indiscretions Forbes
NebuAd to come under spotlight at Senate hearing The Associated Press
Putting Web monitoring service NebuAd under the legal microscope Los Angeles Times
New York Times - ITworld.com
all 116 news articles


Slowing Economy Hits Online Advertising
Adweek, NY - 14 hours ago
Respondents indicated an expectation Internet advertising would grow slightly more than 16 percent in the next year. In its previous surveys, William Blair ...
William Blair & Company and CIMA Release Fifth Installment of ... Business Wire (press release)
all 13 news articles


Magna Cuts Ad Growth Forecast to 2%
Wall Street Journal - 2 hours ago
Mr. Coen's forecast came a day after media analyst Lee Westerfield cut his ad-spending forecast by a similar degree, saying US advertising was experiencing ...
Economic gloom leads to cuts in ad forecast Reuters
New-Media Ad Outlook Remains Buoyant Broadcasting & Cable
Ad Spending Forecast Lowered Again New York Times
Adweek - AdAge.com (subscription)
all 20 news articles


Fusion Advertising Wins Rudolph Foods Account
FOXBusiness - 15 hours ago
DALLAS, July 7, 2008 /PRNewswire via COMTEX/ ----Global snack giant Rudolph Foods today announced its selection of Fusion Advertising as agency of record ...


OnMobile Launches Ad RingBack Tones, Revolutionary Platform for ...
FOXBusiness - 14 hours ago
Arvind Rao, CEO and Co-founder of OnMobile said, "AdRBT is a disruptive evolution in mobile advertising and marketing which so far has been limited to SMS ...


Advertising isn't in keeping with medium's benefits
Economic Times, India - 6 hours ago
One of the striking phenomena of the advertising business during the past decade has been the emergence of the internet as an advertising medium. ...


'2010 will be the tipping point for digital advertising'
Sify, India - 4 hours ago
Excerpts: What prompted you to get into the online advertising space with Media2Win? I don't believe that traditional agencies in India have a clue about ...


Screen Rant

Digital Media Threatens Conventional Media Advertising
Screen Rant, UT - 1 hour ago
DiClemente added that DVR’s are also hurting the advertising revenue that the TV industry has become accustomed to. Of course, earlier I touched on the ...


Google Push to Sell Ads
Wall Street Journal - 1 hour ago
YouTube is critical to Google's campaign to extend its advertising reach far beyond text ads tied to Web searches, its revenue powerhouse. ...
Google's YouTube ad revenue short of expectations: report Reuters
all 4 news articles


News-Leader names new advertising director
News-Leader.com, MO - 12 hours ago
By Kathleen O'Dell • News-Leader • July 8, 2008 Marty Goodnight, a 32-year-old Kansas City Star advertising executive, has been named advertising director ...

Advertising - Google News

home | site map
© 2006