Politics Information

Bush and Kerry Differ on Immigration Policies


Up until the final debate at Arizona State University, the issue of immigration had not been much discussed. Both presidential candidates know very well that illegal immigration is a hot button topic in our country, and each man is now trying to use it to his political advantage. Since the eighties the Democratic Party has, in general, supported immigrants and has been for fair and just immigration laws.

However, there are those members of the party who claim that the presence of millions of undocumented immigrants undermines the bargaining power of the US born labor force. On the other side, the Republican Party traditionally has been against immigrants, but is increasingly reaching out to the Latino population. Advocates of free markets within the party have flat out called for the opening of the borders.

BUSH ON IMMIGRATION.

  • Because of his policies, the Mexican border is now more secure.

  • Proposed temporary guest-worker program, for up to 6 years (originally announced in Jan 2004) but is against amnesty for illegal workers.

  • Claims that our southern border is more secure now than before 911, partly due to his efforts, which include:

    • More than a thousand additional border control agents since he took office.

    • Un-manned vehicles patrolling the US-Mexico border.

    KERRY ON IMMIGRATION.

  • Our southern border is now more of a security risk.

  • Would put illegal immigrants on a path to citizenship.

  • Proposes a comprehensive immigration reform bill with four major components:

    • Undocumented workers who have lived and worked in the U.S. for 5 years, pay taxes, and who are successfully screened for security purposes will be given a path to citizenship.

    • Eliminate the administrative backlog and delay, which have left many families divided.

    • Create a secure channel for a limited number of temporary workers to come into the United States.

    • Kerry would restore legal immigrants' eligibility for health care, welfare and other government programs. (The 1996 welfare reform law made most legal immigrants, including those already in the United States for a number of years, ineligible for welfare, health care and other essential programs.)

    Unfortunately, the reality is that little of significance will be done about immigration under either a Bush or Kerry administration. Immigration is an issue which is brought up when it is time to court voters; namely Latinos. Kerry, like Bush is also close to corporations and businesses that wish to continue their supply of cheap, exploitable labor. He speaks of a path to citizenship for hardworking undocumented immigrants, but how hard will he push for these proposals in Congress? Bush proposed a temporary worker program in Jan. of 2004 (with no plan for becoming green card holders), but nothing at all has come of it.

    These gestures are mostly political pandering. Democrats tend to be more immigrant friendly, but remember it was Reagan who gave undocumented workers amnesty in this country. Republicans are better, though, at fanning the flames of immigrant hate. Immigration is an issue which needs to be addressed seriously, not simply with one-liners at election time. Kerry promises more, but promises can be empty. For Bush, immigrants are to be courted for elections and also used as fodder. When the economy is not doing well, it is easy to blame illegal immigrants.

    About The Author

    Victor Motak

    For more information visit: U.S. Immigration Guide - http://www.visa2003.com/ - providing information on paths to legalized status in the United States.


    MORE RESOURCES:

    The Associated Press

    Obama says he'll 'fix broken politics'
    The Associated Press - 3 hours ago
    DENVER (AP) — Barack Obama promised an end to the "broken politics in Washington and the failed presidency of George W. Bush" Thursday night as he embarked ...
    Video: Obama Compares McCain To Bush CBS
    Obama, McCain taking the fun out of politics amNewYork
    Personal About Politics: Sound Bites & Highlights from the DNC Gather.com
    New York Times - Scripps News
    all 1,894 news articles


    ABC News

    Convention Q&A: Hurricane Politics
    Wall Street Journal Blogs, NY - 3 hours ago
    Deborah Langhoff, a convention delegate from New Orleans, wasn’t too much involved in organized politics until a few years ago. She had volunteered as an ...
    Video: Evacuation Preps Ahead of Hurricane Gustav AssociatedPress
    all 4,008 news articles


    Washington Post

    Politics, Spectacle and History Under Open Sky
    New York Times, United States - 41 minutes ago
    Parents brought children from as far away as Africa, and delegates munched Bronco Brats and clicked cellphone pictures of a political carnival that bore no ...
    Reuters Politics Summary Washington Post
    Power of the orator may propel senator to the very top guardian.co.uk
    BLOOMBERG "MONEY & POLITICS" LIVE FROM THE DEMOCRATIC NATIONAL ... Federal News Service (subscription)
    South Florida Caribbean News - Sydney Morning Herald
    all 557 news articles


    Analysis: 'Born in the USA' returns to politics
    The Associated Press - 56 minutes ago
    It was a significant moment — and a sign that, unlike in Reagan's 1984 campaign, the Democrats are exhibiting savvy about their use of music in political ...


    New York Daily News

    Minority politics Britain’s Obama
    Economist, UK - 11 hours ago
    “WE’RE looking at the politics of hope, as opposed to the politics of fear.” That sentiment has spurred millions of Americans to support Barack Obama this ...
    Obama's Success Ends `I Can't' Attitude for Blacks in Politics Bloomberg
    Post-Racial Politics? — Roots of Racism Run Deeper than Obama’s ... Socialist Alternative
    Obamania spurs African Media Coverage of US Politics - PART 5 OF 5 Voice of America
    Politics In Color - The Associated Press
    all 248 news articles


    Convention Q&A: Gov. David Paterson on Race and Politics
    Wall Street Journal Blogs, NY - 5 hours ago
    It was never about political justice. It was about social justice. It was about the feeling that people who support women and women themselves would feel ...


    A sneak peak inside Xcel Energy Center is charged with politics
    Minneapolis Star Tribune, MN - 1 hour ago
    By candidate: By donor: The Republicans unveiled a 42-inch-high wood laminate podium and stage Thursday at the Xcel Energy Center, and immediately used it ...


    San Francisco Chronicle

    Barkley Turns To Politics
    San Francisco Chronicle,  USA - 5 hours ago
    The 45-year-old Alabama native joined a legion of celebrities at this week's historic Democratic National Convention, where he spoke of his hopes of ...


    Economist

    Politics this week
    Economist, UK - 11 hours ago
    See article Ibrahim Gambari, a UN envoy, left Myanmar after a six-day visit intended to promote political reconciliation. But he failed to see either the ...


    The Associated Press

    Romney: Democrats using 'politics of envy'
    San Francisco Chronicle,  USA - Aug 27, 2008
    By KATHLEEN HENNESSEY, AP Writer Potential vice presidential nominee Mitt Romney accused Democrats on Wednesday of playing "the politics of envy" in recent ...
    Video: Mitt Romney At The DNC? CBS
    Personnel Profile Capitol Weekly
    The strange politics of kingmakers in corn ethanol country MinnPost.com
    TIME - CQPolitics.com
    all 2,266 news articles

    Politics - Google News

  • home | site map
    © 2006