Politics Information

What Price Loyalty?


With the recent shakeups in the presidential cabinet, it has frequently been observed that the quality most treasured in the present administration is that of loyalty.

Is that such an admirable quality?

We prize the loyalty of our friends who protect our good name when we are not present. We respect the loyalty of committed couples who stay true to each other no matter the outside temptations. We recognize the loyalty of employees who stand by their ethics and keep competitors and enemies at bay. We treasure the loyalty of a soldier to his commander, if necessary to the death. We revere the loyalty of believers in their god and their unswerving commitment to their tenets of faith. We equate disloyalty with treason, dishonor, betrayal. We use names like Quisling, Benedict Arnold, Burgess and Hiss as epithets to express our loathing and disgust.

But loyalty has a darker side. In crime families, loyalty means embracing death or imprisonment rather than exposing crime, violence, and murder. In prison, the most despised inmate is the "snitch" who fails to stay silent about his knowledge of criminal acts, plots, and planned violence. Within adolescent groups and street gangs, the rule of silence and total loyalty is an absolute requirement for continued membership.

The old courts of kings and emperors were rife with sycophants: whatever the leader wanted to hear, they offered. Disagreements and alternative plans for the direction of governance were considered intrigue - dangerous differences of opinion to be rooted out and permanently excised from the body politic.

Where does the White House fit in? For all the positive connotations that loyalty may engender, we must look to the extent it is used and continually monitor it for abuse. No one would suggest that a President surround himself with staff who constantly criticize his ideas or regularly publicly disagree with his programs and proposals. However, the negative aspect of over-loyalty - zealousness - must be confronted if the goal is to weave plans for the common good through compromise in the face of diverse opinion.

The United States was born out of public political and ideological debate. While the framers of the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution has fundamental beliefs in common, they did not hesitate to publicly disagree and argue in an effort to reach the most workable goals. For more than two centuries, American political discourse has embraced differences more often than celebrating similarities. Commonly, the friction and arguments of elections become translated into legislation and leadership that seeks to bridge the gaps and bring all into the common fold.

What seems to have changed is the willingness to let disparate views and opinions coexist. We have moved from a mentality that celebrates diversity and multiplicity to a narrow conception of what is right, absolutely right. Other opinions are not valued for the richness their views add to the national fabric but are considered wrong, without value, discounted, dangerously unpatriotic. The second term White House has purified its dogma, filtering our nuances and opposing ideas until everything is distilled into the single voice of one man. The moat around the faithful has been filled, the crocs loosed, and the land lies fallow beneath the keen eye of the true believers.

Arrogance and disdain, disguised as "political capital," has the potential to morph into a level of power and intolerance that can only encourage eventual, inevitable, corruption.

Virginia Bola is a licensed clinical psychologist with deep interests in Social Psychology and politics. She has performed therapeutic services for more than 20 years and has studied the results of cultural forces and employment on the individual. The author of an interactive workbook, The Wolf at the Door: An Unemployment Survival Manual, and a monthly ezine, The Worker's Edge, she can be reached at http://www.virginiabola.com


MORE RESOURCES:

Seattle Post Intelligencer

Changing tone in US politics
The Nation Newspaper, Barbados - 13 hours ago
There is no doubt that Obama's candidacy has brought a refreshing change to the political dynamics in the United States. He has brought charm and confidence ...
Video: Candidates' Goals For Mideast CBS
Politics taints military service Boston Globe
Why is the Media Still Calling Obama the "Presumptive" Nominee ... Huffington Post
Toronto Star - Newsweek
all 3,408 news articles


Clout Street: Politics Explained
Chicago Tribune, United States - 11 hours ago
By Rick Pearson | Chicago Tribune political writer In an election year dominated by the rallying cry of change, an unlikely coalition of some of the state's ...


DEJA VU: Politics, rock 'n' roll meet in new Crosby, Stills, Nash ...
San Diego Union Tribune, United States - 58 minutes ago
That's why this film -- part concert documentary, part political commentary, part human drama -- often focuses on the loss of life, along with the shattered ...


Atlantic Online

Dark Knight Politics
Atlantic Online - 3 hours ago
Instead, it makes everybody think about the present political situation but we'll probably reach different conclusions about it just as we reach different ...


Vanity Fair Misses the Point: It's not McCain's Physique -- It's ...
Yahoo! News - 14 hours ago
It's not her looks, it's her wealth the media understate, and it's not his physique, it's his politics. To do the media hit job fairly, Vanity Fair should ...
New Yorker editors should have known better TheChronicleHerald.ca
Barack Obama Videos Sky News
Vanity Fair McCain Cover Times of the Internet
all 77 news articles


Gather.com

Personal About Politics: Obama’s Trip a Huge Hit, McGaff’s Week a ...
Gather.com, MA - 2 hours ago
Next McCain accused Obama of using the trip for political reasons. Well, yes he is. Isn’t that the whole point, to improve relations with other countries, ...
Washington Post National Political Reporter Washington Post
Op-Ed Columnist All Hail ‘McBama’ New York Times
Washington Post Slams Obama for Opposing Success of Iraq Troop Surge FOXNews
Washington Post
all 19 news articles


Bleacher Report

NASCAR and Politics: Why It's Not a Good Idea
Bleacher Report, CA - 5 hours ago
But, writes Kelly Crandall, that doesn't mean we need to mix racing and politics. by Kelly Crandall (Scribe) On any given Sunday, 43 stock cars are turned ...


RNC Launches New Radio Ad in Paris, USA: 'Obama Chooses Washington ...
MarketWatch - 6 hours ago
Obama chose Washington politics over the needs of our military. As a veteran and someone who has always put the public interest first, John McCain stood by ...
Obama Buys Olympics Airtime, While RNC Runs Spot In Paris...Maine CBS News
all 22 news articles


Voice of America

Editorial: Why Bush should inject politics into Olympic visit
San Jose Mercury News,  USA - Jul 23, 2008
But he's living in a dream world if he believes politics and the Olympics "don't mix," as he told US Olympians at the White House on Monday. ...
Video: Bush Gives Olympians a White House Sendoff AssociatedPress
Shealah Craighead/White House ESPN Magazine
all 585 news articles


Bad luck or bad politics?
Monessen Valley Independent, PA - 3 hours ago
Two casino projects in Philadelphia are languishing in the middle of a political fight. Early this year Mayor Michael Nutter revoked a construction license ...

Politics - Google News

home | site map
© 2006